As recently noted, on July 26, 2018, the 3-Member Appeal Penal Court of Athens gave its verdict on the Schinoussa case, in which Dr. Christos Tsirogiannis has been one of the main witnesses for the Greek State against the Papadimitriou family (heir of the dealer Christos Michaelides, partner of Robin Symes, antiquities dealers). After sending (27.07.2018) to Dr. Tsirogiannis their first letter, through their London lawyers Bird and Bird LLP (Commentary regarding the allegations made in the text of this letter to Tsirogiannis can be found on the blog of antiquities trafficking researcher Dr. Samuel Hardy here), the day after the conviction (26.07.2018) of Despina and Dimitris Papadimitriou by the Greek court, the same day (27.07.2018) they sent two Subject Access Requests to the two universities where he is affiliated: one to the University of Glasgow (download here) and one to the University of Suffolk (download here). Two days ago (05.09.2018) the same legal office, representing again all four Papadimitriou family members, sent another Subject Access Request to Dr. Cristos Tsirogiannis directly.
Background (copied from the ARCA Art Crime blog and written by Lynda Albertson):
The objects which led to this reported conviction were confiscated twelve years ago from the family’s villa on the Aegean island of Schinoussa as well as at a second family residence in the suburb of Psychiko, in northern Athens.
The antiquities connected to these charges were held on that occasion in accordance with Greek Law 3028/2002 on the Protection of Antiquities and Cultural Heritage in General along with a significant number of photographic images, many of which represent additional antiquities, not recovered on the properties during the aforementioned Greek raids. The objects portrayed in the photos are related to the commercial transactions of antiquities dealers Christo Michaelides and Robin Symes who sold ancient art through Robin Symes Limited.
According to the book “The Medici Conspiracy” the 17 albums of photographic documentation seized, often referred to as the “Schinoussa archive” depict 995 artifacts in 2,191 photos. The bulk of the images, shot by professional photographers. The binders are said to be derived from the most important antiquities which are known to have passed through Symes and Michaelides’ hands at some point during their business dealings from the 1980s through the 1990s.
While photographs from the Schinoussa archive do not, in and of themselves, prove that a specifically photographed antiquity is illicit in origin, the images photographed can raise disturbing questions about which middleman hands unprovenanced antiquities have passed through. What we do know is that the Symes – Michaelides duo sold objects tied to other traffickers in completion of transactions to wealthy collectors and some of the most prestigious museums in the world.
An example of this is the recently repatriated calyx-krater mixing vessel attributed to Python, as painter which was returned to Italy. This object was purchased by Speed Art Museum through Robin Symes Limited, on the basis that the krater came from a private collector in Paris. Instead the object was found to match photos from the Giacomo Medici archive, where the antiquity is depicted in an unrestored, and obviously looted, state. This means the French provenance applied to the object and relayed to the museum was a fabrication. It is for this reason, that objects represented in the Schinoussa archive and/or sold via Robin Symes Limited, in circulation within the world’s thriving antiquities art market deserve careful scrutiny as they may represent antiquities derived from illegal sources.
At the time of the Schinoussa and Psychiko villa searches, in April of 2006, the resulting haul of undocumented antiquities was considered to be the largest antiquities seizure by law enforcement in recent Greek history. In total, some 152 undocumented ancient artworks were inventoried by investigating authorities. Later, evaluations by two committees of experts were held in order to determine which objects were authentic and therefore subject to seizure under existing Greek law. The committee also looked at what might merely be fakes or reproductions.
Some of the notable objects identified on the Papadimitriou properties included two large Egyptian sphinxes made of pink granite, nine rare Coptic weavings from the fourth-to-sixth centuries C.E., multiple marble busts, Corinthian capitals, and Byzantine architectural elements. There was even a fake statue that was once displayed at the Getty Museum. One of the more unusual finds was the remains of an entire 17th century building which had been dismantled, perhaps to be reconstructed elsewhere at some later date.
Officers also found shipment boxes from Christie’s auction house which included market transactions from 2001 through 2005. Notably, many of the objects found during the executed search warrants were still wrapped, either having never been unwrapped, or perhaps having been rewrapped, awaiting transport elsewhere. At the end of the committee evaluations a total 69 objects were confiscated by the authorities. Their total estimated value: a little more than €982,000 euros.
Those who follow illicit trafficking will already be familiar with the name of deceased antiquities dealer Christo Michaelides, who, prior to his death was the former partner of Robin Symes. Michaelidis lived with Symes from the 1970s until his death on 5 July 1999 as a result of a fatal fall which occurred during a dinner party in a villa in Terni, Italy hosted by the now famous American antiquities collectors, Leon Levy and Shelby White.
Michaelides descended from a Greek shipping family, run by his father, Alexander Votsi Michaelides. His sister is Despina Papadimitriou, is one of the four original defendants charged by Greek prosecutor Eleni Raikou seven months after the Schinoussa and Psychiko seizures. The other individuals named in this case are Despina’s three adult children, Dimitri, Alexis, and Angeliki, though it appears that the court has ruled negatively on solely Despina and Dimitri.
“ancient monuments, cultural goods dating back to prehistoric, ancient, Byzantine and post-Byzantine times until 1830.”
(Greek «ιδιοποιήθηκαν παράνομα αρχαία μνημεία, πολιτιστικά αγαθά που ανάγονται στους προϊστορικούς, αρχαίους, βυζαντινούς και μεταβυζαντινούς χρόνους έως και το 1830»)
“There is an aim of income generation and a constant propensity to commit the crime, which is directed against the State, the embezzlement of monuments as an element of their personality.”(Greek «Προκύπτει σκοπός για πορισμό εισοδήματος και σταθερή ροπή προς τη διάπραξη του εγκλήματος, που στρέφεται κατά του Δημοσίου, της υπεξαίρεσης μνημείων ως στοιχείο της προσωπικότητάς τους».)
This statement is perplexing given her brother’s longterm ties to his partner, Robin Symes, and the pair’s business dealings with well-publicised dealers of ancient art who were already known to be involved in the handling and selling of tainted illicit antiquities.
As this court decision moves forward to the second judicial phase it is interesting to note that London lawyers on behalf of all four members of the Papadimitriou family named in this court case have sent a lengthy letter, written one day after the Court’s decision, to one of the Greek state’s witnesses who testified on behalf of the government during their trial. The contents of this four-page letter, written to Cambridge-based forensic archaeologist Christos Tsirogiannis, might be interpreted as witness intimidation.
One thought on “GREECE: Verdict on the Schinoussa case and intimidation of witness part 2”
Pingback: Archaeologist threatened by Giacomo Medici | EAA-Committee on the Illicit Trade in Cultural Material